Outsourced EmploymentPowered by StealthAgents

Practical guide

Create a recognition nomination record that cites the stated criteria

A recognition nomination that names the criterion, records the evidence, and shows the reviewer how the choice was made.

Published

Practical guide illustration for Create a recognition nomination record that cites the stated criteria
Table of contents

Publish the criteria before nominations open

Write the criteria for the recognition before anyone is nominated. The criteria may cover customer care, teamwork, a safety habit, or a difficult project. Record the definition of each one so nominators apply the same test. A program that invents criteria after the names arrive cannot be fair.

State who is eligible and which period the recognition covers. Record the start and end dates and the roles included. A nomination for work outside the period should be marked as out of scope. The rule should be the same for every team.

Explain how many people can be recognized and what the recognition includes. Record the limit and the process for a tie. A vague promise of something nice creates expectations that the program may not meet. The nomination form should match the published description.

Ask for one criterion and one example

Require the nominator to choose one criterion from the published list. A nomination that checks every box is harder to compare than one that makes a clear case. Record the chosen criterion at the top of the form. The reviewer can then read the example against the right standard.

Ask for a specific example with a date, a task, and a result the reader can verify. A general statement that someone is great gives the reviewer nothing to weigh. Record the source of the example, such as a project record or a customer note. The evidence should be something the employee would be comfortable seeing.

Ask the nominator to say what changed because of the work. A result may be a faster handoff, a calmer customer, or a safer step. Record the change in plain language. The answer shows whether the example meets the criterion or only sounds impressive.

Review nominations against the same standard

Give every reviewer the same criteria, the same period, and the same evidence rule. Record the review date and the names of the reviewers. A panel that sees different material cannot make a consistent choice. The record should show that the process was shared.

Score each nomination on the chosen criterion and the strength of the evidence. Keep the scale short and define what each point means. Record the scores and a one-line reason for each. A score without a reason is hard to explain to the employee or to an auditor.

Check the set of nominations for patterns before the final choice. A team that never appears may be overlooked rather than less deserving. Record the pattern and any step taken to seek more nominations. The review should notice who is missing, not only who is present.

Tell each nominator and employee what happened

Tell the nominator whether the nomination was selected and why. Record the date and the channel. A person who took time to nominate deserves an answer even when the result is a decline. The reason should point to the criterion, not to a personal judgment.

Tell the employee who was recognized what the nomination said and who submitted it. Record that the employee received the message. A recognition that stays in a management folder misses its purpose. The employee should be able to see the example that earned the notice.

Close the cycle with a short review of the criteria and the form. Record what worked, what confused nominators, and one change for the next round. Keep the records under the retention rule for recognition and personnel files. A closed cycle makes the next one easier to trust.

Sources

References supplied with this guide.

Article source directory
SourcePublisherContext
U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, Prohibited Employment Policies and Practiceseeoc.govPrimary reference supplied with this article.
U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, Recordkeeping Requirementseeoc.govPrimary reference supplied with this article.
National Labor Relations Board, What We Donlrb.govPrimary reference supplied with this article.