Outsourced EmploymentPowered by StealthAgents

Practical guide

Run a quarterly spot check on timekeeping imports

A quarterly timekeeping spot check that freezes the import, compares identities before hours, traces every mismatch, and records the correction.

Published

Practical guide illustration for Run a quarterly spot check on timekeeping imports
Table of contents

Freeze the import and the approved schedule

Save the import file and the approved schedule as they existed at the same moment. Record the export time, the time zone, the period, and the person who produced each file. A later version of either source should not enter the sample. The frozen pair is the evidence the check will use.

Include the rule or roster version that governed the period. A schedule that changed after the period can make a correct import look wrong. Note the effective date of the rule and any approved exceptions. The reviewer needs to know which version was in force before judging the import.

Keep the frozen files in an approved location rather than a personal download folder. The location should be accessible to the reviewer and protected from casual edits. Record a checksum or a stable file identifier when the system supports one. The goal is to reproduce the check later without guessing which file was used.

Compare identities before comparing hours

Check that every imported record matches one active employee identifier. Look for duplicate identifiers, inactive employees with hours, and names that appear under two records. An identity mismatch can move hours to the wrong person even when the total is correct. Resolve identity before reviewing the amounts.

Compare the employee population in the import with the population in the approved schedule. List anyone present in one source and missing from the other. A new hire or a leaver near the period boundary is a common explanation. Record the explanation rather than deleting the row from the sample.

Check the mapping between the timekeeping system and the payroll system for identifiers that changed during the quarter. A transferred employee may carry an old location code or a new department label. The import can be valid while the mapping sends the hours to the wrong reporting group. Record the mapping version with the sample.

Check the boundaries where imports usually fail

Review the first and last day of the period, because boundary errors are common and easy to miss. Compare the hours at the start and end of the week with the schedule and the approved exceptions. Check overnight shifts, holiday rules, and time zone changes separately. A boundary error can shift hours into the next period without changing the total.

Test employees who changed schedule or status during the period. A promotion, a leave start, or a location move can create two valid rates in one period. The import should show the effective date and the correct split. Review the split rather than accepting a blended total.

Check overtime, premium, and unpaid break rules against the approved policy version. The import may carry the right hours but apply the wrong rule. Record the rule and the version used for the sample. If the rule changed during the period, review the change date before treating a difference as an error.

Trace each mismatch to its source

For every difference, name the source that should govern the value. The source may be the approved schedule, a manager correction, a leave record, or the timekeeping system itself. Do not choose the source that makes the import look correct. The reviewer should record why that source governs and who approved it.

Separate an import defect from a source defect. A missing punch is a source problem, while a correctly captured punch that arrives under the wrong employee is an import problem. The repair path differs, and combining them hides what to fix. Label each difference before assigning an owner.

Keep the original value and the corrected value in the record. A correction that overwrites the evidence makes the next review harder. Record the date, the reviewer, and the approval for the correction. If the correction affects pay, route it through the approved payroll process rather than editing the import file.

Record the correction and the reviewer

Write a short correction log with the employee identifier, the period, the field, the original value, the corrected value, and the reason. Link the log to the frozen files and the approval. The log should be readable by someone who did not run the check. Avoid copying sensitive details that the reviewer does not need.

Ask a second person to review the corrections before the next pay run. The reviewer checks that the correction matches the source and that no new difference was introduced. Record the review date and any item returned for more evidence. A second look is especially important when the correction changes pay.

Close the check with a count of items reviewed, differences found, corrections made, and items still open. A check that ends with only a narrative cannot be compared with the next quarter. The counts show whether the process is improving or repeating. Keep the counts beside the sample method.

Turn repeat findings into a schedule change

Group the differences by cause across the quarter and the prior check. A repeated boundary error may point to a schedule rule that the import cannot represent. A repeated identity error may point to a missing identifier in the source. The pattern is more useful than any single correction.

Assign one owner to the most frequent cause and set a review date for the fix. The owner should be able to change the source, the mapping, or the import rule. A fix that only adds another manual check leaves the underlying problem in place. Record the expected change and how it will be tested.

Review the fix in the next quarter with the same sample method. If the cause disappears, retire the extra manual step. If it remains, inspect the source again before adding more review. The purpose of the spot check is a cleaner import, not a longer checklist.

Sources

References supplied with this guide.

Article source directory
SourcePublisherContext
Internal Revenue Service, Publication 15irs.govPrimary reference supplied with this article.
U.S. Department of Labor, Recordkeepingdol.govPrimary reference supplied with this article.
National Institute of Standards and Technology, Cybersecurity Framework 2.0nist.govPrimary reference supplied with this article.
U.S. Department of Labor, Fair Labor Standards Actdol.govPrimary reference supplied with this article.