Research note
What share of recognition nominations cite the stated criteria?
A local method for measuring how often recognition nominations cite the stated criteria, with separate checks for the example, the reviewer, and the outcome note.
Published

Table of contents
Question and scope
The question covers nominations submitted through a written recognition program. It includes peer nominations, manager nominations, and self-nominations where the program allows them. It excludes informal thank-you messages that were never part of a round. The review covers one employer, one round or window, and the roles that can take part.
A nomination enters the sample when the program record shows a submitted form and a round date. If the nomination was sent by message and later added to the record, the case enters as an informal submission. Record the source of the criteria and the date the round opened. A form submitted after the deadline should be marked as late.
The stop point is a reviewer decision recorded against the published criteria, not a shortlist message. A decision may be a selection, a decline, or a request for more evidence. The record should show which criterion was applied. Report nominations with no decision separately.
Definitions and evidence standard
Define a complete nomination before reviewing any case. It should name one published criterion, give an example with a date, and describe the result of the work. A nomination that lists several criteria without a clear example does not meet the standard. Record the definition with the case so a later reader applies the same rule.
Use the nomination form, the criteria page, and the reviewer note as the primary evidence. A conversation about the employee can add context but cannot replace a dated example. If only a verbal report exists, mark the case as unverified rather than assigning a date. Report the share of unverified cases with the result.
Separate the nomination from the decision. A strong nomination can still be declined when the round has a limit, and a weak nomination can be selected by mistake. Measure both stages so one does not stand in for the other. The two numbers answer different questions about the program.
Sampling and measurement
Freeze the list of nominations before reviewing any of them. Include more than one team, more than one nominator type, and more than one round if the window allows. Record the export date and the filter used. Do not remove a nomination because the form is incomplete, since the gaps are part of the finding.
If the list is large, take a random sample and record the selection method. Keep the full count beside the sample so a reader can see the coverage. A replaced case should be reported as a deviation. The sample should be large enough to compare at least two teams.
Measure the number of nominations, the share citing a published criterion, the share with a dated example, and the share with a recorded decision. Add the number with no criterion and the number with no example. Report the counts by team and nominator type. A single percentage hides which group drives the gap.
Findings and interpretation
Present the distribution before suggesting a cause. A cluster of unscored nominations under one manager may mean the criteria were never shared with that team. A cluster in one round may mean the form changed and the old fields remained. Read the cases behind the largest cluster before naming a reason.
Compare the result with the nomination method. A form with a required criterion field may produce a clearer case than a free-text message. Record the method and the first person who read the nomination. The comparison can show whether the gap is in the form or the review.
Check whether declined nominations received a reason and whether the employee was told. A clear reason tied to the criterion is different from a silent refusal. Record the date of the notice and the channel. The quality of the answer matters alongside the selection.
Limitations
The review measures whether a nomination cites the criteria, not whether the choice was fair. A well-formed nomination can still hide bias. The result describes the documentation trail, not the outcome. Report it beside a review of the selected group so a reader does not overread the number.
The criteria may change during the window, and an older nomination may follow a rule that was appropriate at the time. Record the criteria version rather than applying the current rule retroactively. A nomination that missed an old standard may not be a current defect. Keep the version note with the case file.
An employee who was never nominated is invisible to this method. The count may understate the gap if some teams never take part. Pair the review with a count of eligible employees by team. The answer can reveal a gap the nomination record cannot show.
Practical next step
Publish the criteria and make the criterion field required on the nomination form. A required field is easier to enforce than a reminder. Record the date the form changed and the round it applies to. Tell nominators where to find the criteria before the round opens.
Give reviewers one scoring sheet tied to the criteria and a place for a short reason. Record the score and the reason for every nomination. Tell each nominator the result and the criterion that was applied. The answer should be specific enough that a person can learn from it.
Test the process for one round and compare the cited share with the baseline. Keep the change if it improves the trail without discouraging nominations. If the form or the feedback step causes errors, fix that step. The goal is a clear, fair recognition process, not more forms.
Sources
References supplied with this research note.
| Source | Publisher | Context |
|---|---|---|
| U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, Prohibited Employment Policies and Practices | eeoc.gov | Primary reference supplied with this article. |
| U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, Recordkeeping Requirements | eeoc.gov | Primary reference supplied with this article. |
| National Labor Relations Board, What We Do | nlrb.gov | Primary reference supplied with this article. |